The Girl with No Reflection (Keshe Chow, Penguin)

The Girl with No Reflection by Keshe Chow is a debut YA historical fantasy novel set in Imperial China, drawing on Chinese mythology. The story begins with Ying, a young noblewoman, who, on the eve of her wedding to a cold and distant prince, notices that her reflection in a pond is smiling, while she is not. She then discovers a mysterious mirror world beyond her reflection, with another version of the prince who is kind and warm; but all is not as it seems, and something sinister lurks beneath. The novel starts strongly, with a compellingly eerie atmosphere that draws readers in with mystery, intrigue and action. The first few chapters are particularly gripping and set the tone for a thrilling blend of fantasy and horror. As the story progresses, romance becomes a central element, which may appeal to some readers, while others may find it somewhat conventional. The fantasy and horror aspects, initially so promising, become secondary as the focus shifts. Despite this shift, those looking for familiar tropes, such as ‘instalove’, will find much to enjoy here. While the world-building could be more detailed, the novel still provides an engaging concept and setting. The language is accessible and uncomplicated, although some mature content and offensive language make this more suited to readers aged 14+. It will likely appeal to readers who enjoyed Only a Monster by Vanessa Len.

Books+Publishing reviewer: George Banach-Salas is a queer, non binary teacher, writer and former bookseller living in Tāmaki Makaurau, Aotearoa. Books+Publishing is Australia’s number-one source of pre-publication book reviews.

Category: Friday Unlocked reviews Reviews